The Land We Carry: Ancestry, Culture, and Our Relationship with Place

The Acorn Eaters

For several years, my son and I made a habit of gathering acorns. We lived in Southern California, where coast live oak trees were abundant, and each year we would collect the acorns, process them, grind them into flour, and leach out their tannins so we could save the flour for later use. It became something we looked forward to doing together. There was something satisfying about gathering food ourselves, knowing where it came from, and putting in the work to make it usable. I also enjoyed teaching my son to recognize a food resource that was growing all around us.

Every now and then, someone would question why we were doing it. Acorns were not a traditional staple in either of our ancestral foodways, so some people jokingly referred to us as the acorn eaters. I understood the humor, but I also found the question interesting. Why should our relationship with the land be limited to the foods our ancestors gathered? Acorns were an important staple for many Indigenous communities in California. They were part of the ecology and history of the place where we lived. I was not trying to claim another community's traditions or knowledge. I simply saw a resource growing in our environment and wanted to learn how to use it.

My son is Lakota, and I wanted him to grow up understanding the importance of his heritage, including the relationship between Lakota people and the buffalo. But we were living in Southern California, not on the Plains. Buffalo were not part of our immediate environment or daily lives. That did not make his Lakota heritage any less meaningful, nor did it mean that every relationship we developed with the natural world had to revolve around the landscape of his ancestors. We could honor his connection to buffalo while also learning to gather acorns. Those things were not in competition.

The experience made me think about how we understand our relationship with the natural world, particularly when we live far from the places our ancestors called home. Sometimes we become so focused on maintaining a connection to ancestral landscapes that we overlook the opportunity to develop one with the land beneath our own feet. I began to wonder whether we sometimes mistake cultural continuity for the preservation of a particular way of life, as though our relationship with nature must remain tied to the same plants, animals, and environments our ancestors knew.

I don't believe that has to be the case. We can carry our cultural inheritance with us while also learning from the places where we live. Doing so does not require us to abandon our heritage or pretend that every landscape is interchangeable. It simply means recognizing that our relationship with the natural world can continue to develop throughout our lives.

Teaching Hepan How to Process Acorns

The Land We Inherit

There is a particular kind of disconnection that can come from living far from the landscapes that shaped our ancestors. We may inherit stories, traditions, and ways of understanding the natural world that developed in places we have never visited. The plants and animals associated with those traditions may be absent from our surroundings. We can know the names of the trees our ancestors depended on without ever having seen one growing in its natural environment. We can learn about the animals they hunted, the foods they gathered, and the places they considered sacred while living somewhere that looks and feels entirely different.

For some people, this distance creates the impression that their cultural relationship with nature belongs somewhere else. They may feel that to reconnect with their heritage, they must somehow recreate the environment in which their traditions originated. Others may feel that living far from their ancestral homeland makes it difficult to practice or maintain those traditions at all. I understand that feeling, especially when a tradition is deeply connected to a particular landscape. There are relationships that cannot simply be reproduced elsewhere, and there are places whose significance cannot be separated from their histories.

This is particularly important when discussing Indigenous displacement. Many Indigenous people do not live far from their ancestral homelands by choice. Colonization, forced removal, land dispossession, and the loss of access to traditional territories have separated communities from places that remain central to their identities. Developing a relationship with a new environment does not erase that history, nor should it be treated as a substitute for the land that was taken from them. There is a difference between someone choosing to live somewhere new and a people being forcibly separated from their homeland.

At the same time, displacement does not mean that a cultural relationship with the natural world must end. People carry knowledge, stories, and traditions with them. They continue to teach their children, maintain relationships with their communities, and find ways to practice their culture under circumstances that may be very different from those of previous generations. Some traditions remain closely tied to the original landscape, while others can continue in different forms. Still others may become part of a person's relationship with a new place.

I think the important thing is to recognize that these possibilities do not have to be mutually exclusive. A person can maintain a connection to the land of their ancestors while developing a relationship with the land where they currently live. One does not have to replace the other.

What We Carry With Us

My own heritage has given me several different ways of thinking about the natural world. I have Tewa Pueblo and Mexican Indigenous ancestry, including Mexica heritage, as well as Pennsylvania Dutch heritage. These traditions come from different histories and environments, and I do not approach all of them in the same way. But they have each influenced how I understand the relationship between people and the natural world.

One example comes from my Pennsylvania Dutch heritage and a story by the Brothers Grimm called The Juniper Tree. In the tale, a murdered boy's bones are buried beneath a juniper tree. A bird eventually emerges from the tree, sings, reveals the truth of what happened, and helps bring about the boy's restoration. The story carries themes of death, renewal, and transformation. Juniper also has associations with health, protection, and renewal in various European folk traditions, although those meanings and customs differ across regions.

During a period when I was trying to improve my health and make changes in my life, I made an offering of milk and bread at the base of the juniper tree in my yard. I asked for a new version of myself, someone healthy and lean, with a body capable of doing what my mind asked of it. It was a personal act informed by the stories and symbolism I had inherited. I was not in Germany, standing beneath a tree in the landscape my ancestors knew. I was in my own yard in the American Southwest, interacting with a tree growing in the place where I lived.

Yet the distance did not make the symbolism meaningless. The juniper gave me a way to express something familiar through the environment around me. It reminded me that an inherited way of relating to nature does not necessarily disappear when we leave the landscape where it developed. Sometimes we recognize familiar qualities in the plants and animals around us and find ways to understand them through the knowledge we already carry.

This does not mean that two species are interchangeable simply because they resemble one another. European settlers sometimes named or interpreted North American plants and animals by comparing them to familiar species from their homelands. Those comparisons could provide a starting point for understanding something unfamiliar, but the new species still had to be learned on its own terms. Similar appearances do not necessarily mean identical ecological roles, behaviors, or uses. We can draw on what we already know without assuming that everything in a new environment works the same way.

I think this is an important part of carrying culture with us. Our inherited knowledge gives us a foundation, but it should not prevent us from learning. We do not have to discard what we know in order to understand something new, just as we should not assume that everything new must fit neatly into the categories we inherited.

Same Heritage, Different Landscapes

Cultural traditions have always been influenced by the environments in which people live. Even communities with closely related histories and shared cultural foundations can develop different expressions of their traditions. Geography, climate, available resources, neighboring peoples, and shared experiences all contribute to how communities understand and interact with the natural world.

The Dakota and Lakota, for example, are distinct but closely related peoples within the larger Oceti Sakowin. Their histories and regional experiences have contributed to differences in their cultural expressions. It would be a mistake to assume that every community within a broader cultural relationship must maintain identical practices or place the same emphasis on every aspect of its traditions. The same is true of historical Germanic communities. The religious and cultural expressions of people living in Scandinavia were not necessarily identical to those of people living in continental Germanic regions. Shared heritage does not require uniformity.

The same principle applies to people who share experiences and ways of life. Two communities might have similar ancestry but develop different cultural priorities because of the environments in which they live or the circumstances they have experienced together. A community that has spent generations in a desert will naturally develop different relationships with water, plants, and animals than one living along a forested coastline. Those differences do not necessarily indicate that one community has preserved its traditions better than the other. They may simply reflect different relationships with the world around them.

This is also worth considering when looking at modern religious and cultural revival movements. A Heathen community living in the forests of Oregon may develop different seasonal observances and relationships with its surroundings than a Heathen community living in the Nevada desert. Both may draw from the same historical Germanic traditions, but their immediate environments provide different experiences and opportunities. Their shared heritage does not require them to ignore those differences. Likewise, communities with different lifestyles and shared experiences may emphasize different virtues or practices even when they draw from similar traditions.

I think we sometimes place too much emphasis on what a tradition looked like in one particular time or place, as though that expression represents the only legitimate way it can exist. But traditions have always been lived by people under changing circumstances. Their expressions have varied across regions and generations. Cultural continuity does not require every community to look the same.

When the Land Changes Us

The movement of horses across North America offers an especially interesting example of how changes in the natural world can influence the development of entire communities. As a Tewa person, I grew up with an understanding of this history that comes through my own family's cultural perspective. Spanish colonization introduced domestic horses into the Southwest, and the Pueblo Revolt of 1680 became an important turning point in their wider distribution. As Spanish colonial control was disrupted, horses became more accessible to Indigenous communities and spread through networks of trade, exchange, and movement.

The Revolt and its aftermath were important developments in the broader spread and adoption of horses. Indigenous peoples were not simply passive recipients of this animal. They incorporated horses into their own economies, relationships, and ways of life, and the networks through which horses spread were shaped by Indigenous agency.

From the Southwest, horses became part of the lives of many Indigenous peoples across the Plains and Rocky Mountains. They changed how people traveled, hunted, traded, maintained relationships, and defended their communities. The Lakota eventually developed a highly mobile horse culture that became closely associated with their life on the Plains. Their relationship with the horse became part of the way their culture developed under changing historical circumstances. This did not make them any less Lakota.

The emergence of the Comanche offers another particularly striking example. The Comanche emerged from Shoshone-speaking peoples who gradually separated from their Shoshone relatives and moved southward. Their incorporation of horses was central to this transformation. Horses increased their mobility and allowed them to take advantage of the immense buffalo herds and trade opportunities of the Southern Plains. Over time, the people who became known as the Comanche developed a distinct identity, society, and way of life. They remained connected to the Shoshone through ancestry and language, but became a distinct people in their own right.

The horse did not single-handedly create the Comanche identity, but it helped make possible the historical circumstances in which that identity developed. This is more than an example of a community adapting an existing tradition. It shows how a new resource, combined with migration, relationships, and historical opportunity, can contribute to the emergence of an entirely distinct cultural identity.

These histories remind us that Indigenous cultures have never existed in isolation from change or from one another. People have exchanged knowledge, resources, and technologies, and they have adapted to new circumstances in ways that sometimes profoundly transformed their communities. This does not mean that all cultural practices are freely transferable or that the histories of different nations can be collapsed into one another. The Comanche did not become a different people simply because they adopted the horse, and the Lakota did not cease to be Lakota as their relationship with the Plains changed. Their identities developed through their own histories, relationships, and decisions.

Traditions That Take Root

Sometimes cultural traditions adapt to a new environment without losing their underlying meaning. My Pennsylvania Dutch heritage offers a simple example through Groundhog Day, or Grundsau Daag. The custom has roots in European weather lore associated with Candlemas. In parts of Europe, animals such as badgers were associated with predicting the coming weather. When German-speaking immigrants settled in Pennsylvania, they encountered a different animal with similar habits, the groundhog. The custom developed around the animal familiar to their new surroundings. The underlying seasonal observation remained recognizable, but its expression changed to reflect the environment in which the people now lived.

They did not need to import a European badger or abandon the custom simply because the animal associated with it was no longer part of their surroundings. They adapted the tradition to the place where they had settled. This is a relatively simple example, but it illustrates how cultural practices can remain meaningful even when their expressions change.

I encountered an Indigenous example of a similar kind of adaptation while living on the Pine Ridge Reservation. I was told about the Lakota Hunka ceremony, an adoption ceremony through which people establish a kinship relationship. As I remember the explanation, corn once had an important symbolic role in the ceremony. An ear of corn, attached to a stick or wand, represented the generosity of providing for one's new relatives, symbolizing the giving of one's excess corn. With the development of horse culture, I was told, a horse's tail came to be used instead, representing the giving of horses. I may not remember every detail or the exact ceremonial object correctly, but the explanation stayed with me because of what it illustrated. The relationship being established had not changed, but the thing used to express that relationship had. What had once been represented through an important agricultural resource could be expressed through an animal that had become central to the people's way of life.

I find this especially interesting because it demonstrates that cultural adaptation is not necessarily a matter of abandoning an old tradition and replacing it with something unrelated. Sometimes the underlying meaning remains while the expression changes to reflect the circumstances of the people practicing it. Corn and horses occupied different places in Lakota life, but both could represent generosity and the responsibility of providing for one's relatives. The example also reminds us that cultural practices are not always static, even within traditions that carry deep ceremonial significance.

The relationship between the Lakota and the buffalo provides a different example. Unlike Groundhog Day, the buffalo relationship is not simply an old custom that was adapted to a new animal or environment. It remains an important and living part of Lakota culture. Lakota communities continue to care for buffalo herds, and buffalo meat remains important in certain ceremonial and community contexts. The circumstances surrounding the relationship have changed, but the relationship itself has not disappeared.

My son's connection to that heritage does not depend on our family living the way Lakota people lived generations ago. We were not hunting buffalo in Southern California, but that did not prevent him from learning about their importance or maintaining a relationship with his heritage. At the same time, our family could develop new traditions through the resources available to us. Gathering acorns did not replace the buffalo or diminish their importance. It simply became another part of our family's experience.

I think there is a tendency to treat cultural traditions as though they must either remain exactly as they were or be abandoned altogether. But there are more possibilities than that. Some traditions can be maintained in their original form. Others can be adapted to new circumstances. People can also develop new traditions that reflect their experiences and the places where they live. These processes can exist alongside one another.

The important thing is to understand what is being preserved and what is changing. A seasonal custom involving a weather-predicting animal may be relatively easy to adapt. A ceremony tied to a particular sacred place or governed by specific cultural protocols is a very different matter. Recognizing that traditions can change does not mean assuming that every tradition should or can be changed.

The Land Beneath Our Feet

Ultimately, I do not think we have to choose between honoring the places our ancestors came from and developing a meaningful relationship with the places we inhabit today. We can preserve the traditions that remain important to us, adapt those that can appropriately take on new forms, and develop new traditions through our own experiences. We can teach our children where their ancestors came from while also teaching them to recognize the trees, plants, animals, and resources growing around their homes.

My son can grow up understanding the importance of buffalo to his Lakota heritage while also remembering the years we spent gathering acorns together in California. Those experiences are not contradictions. They are different parts of his relationship with the world. And now that I no longer live in California and have moved to New Mexico, the acorns have given way to piƱons. The landscape has changed, and the opportunities it offers have changed with it. I do not need to recreate California here to maintain the meaning of what we did there. I can carry the memory of those experiences while learning what this place has to offer.

I think this is something worth remembering, especially when we feel disconnected from the landscapes of our ancestors. We should not mistake the distance between ourselves and those places for an inability to maintain our cultural inheritance. Nor should we allow that inheritance to keep us from knowing the land where we are. Our ancestors' landscapes can remain part of us without becoming the only landscapes we know. The traditions we inherit can give us a foundation, but they do not have to become boundaries.

A living tradition does not have to look the same everywhere in order to remain meaningful. Sometimes continuity means preserving what came before. Sometimes it means adapting to circumstances. And sometimes it means allowing new relationships to take root. We do not have to abandon where we come from to develop a relationship with where we are. The land we carry with us is important, but so is the land beneath our feet.

Comments