A friend sent me a game on Steam called Flock Around, a bird photography simulator. I had a lot of fun playing it, and the excitement of the game sent me down a rabbit hole. Before long, I wanted to try birding for myself. My first purchase was a pair of binoculars. I took them out into our backyard to see what I could find. The first bird I spotted was a vibrantly colored house finch perched on a cholla cactus. It was only a few feet away, giving me a clear view of its beautiful colors. It almost seemed as though it were allowing me to observe it. There was something wonderful about seeing such a small creature up close and taking the time to appreciate it. I was hooked.
After that, I bought a bird bath and a motion-activated camera feeder. I also started following birding and bird photography groups on Facebook. Seeing the birds other people were photographing and the places they were visiting made me want to take the hobby beyond our backyard. Eventually, my son and I decided to take our binoculars into the mountains and see what we could find.
We went out among the pines and junipers, listening to the birds calling from the trees. Most of them were high up in the canopy, though, so we couldn't get a good look at them. We kept walking, hoping we would eventually spot something, but after a while we started getting discouraged. Eventually, we decided to call it a day and head home. On the way back, we stopped at Walmart. As we were walking through the parking lot, my son spotted a beautiful little blackbird. He pointed at it and said, "Look, a bird." That one sentence instantly killed whatever enthusiasm I had left for birding. There was a moment of silence before we both burst out laughing at the irony of it.
I was ready to move on, so I returned the binoculars, camera feeder, and bird bath. The hobby had lasted almost two weeks. I did, however, continue feeding the birds. They had been visiting the feeder and bath, and I didn't want to abruptly take away a food source I had introduced. With the feeder gone, I started scattering seed in the spot where it had been and decided to keep it up for the rest of the season. I wasn't going to abandon them simply because I had lost interest in the hobby.
| ||
The hobby turned out to be a two-week taste of a different way of relating to nature, one I had never really tried. I already related to the land as a relative and not as a visitor. The hobby showed me what the other way was like. It followed a familiar American pattern. I bought gear, followed other people's photographs, and went out to find birds worth capturing. Underneath it was an idea I hadn't really questioned before, that nature was somewhere you went, a place apart from daily life where you could escape civilization and have an experience. There is a particular idea of wilderness in American culture. We often imagine nature as something distant from our everyday lives. Mountains, forests, deserts, and places where human development has not visibly changed the landscape. We travel to these places to escape civilization and experience something we consider more natural or untouched. There is nothing wrong with enjoying those places, but the distinction we sometimes make between wilderness and the places where we live deserves closer examination.
Environmental historian William Cronon explores this idea in his essay "The Trouble with Wilderness, or Getting Back to the Wrong Nature." He traces how the American understanding of wilderness changed over time. What had once been regarded largely as a frightening, barren, or undesirable place gradually became an idealized landscape, valued as an escape from civilization and a refuge from the influence of human beings. Cronon argues that this modern wilderness ideal is not simply a natural fact. It is a cultural idea shaped by particular moments in American and European history. In the United States, it became closely tied to romanticism, the frontier myth, and the desire to find a place untouched by modern society. He also points out the irony that the creation of some national parks and wilderness areas followed the forced removal of Indigenous people from those very landscapes. The idea of an untouched wilderness could erase the histories of the people who had lived there and maintained relationships with those places for generations.
Cronon's criticism is not that wilderness has no value or that wild places should not be protected. He explicitly recognizes the importance of preserving nonhuman nature. His concern is with the way wilderness can encourage us to imagine that nature is most authentic when human beings are absent. When we make that distinction, the places where we actually live can begin to seem less natural or less worthy of care. We end up treating nature as somewhere else, rather than recognizing the natural world that surrounds us every day. I don't mean to suggest that everyone who enjoys wilderness or goes birdwatching shares this worldview. Nor is this the only way Western people have understood nature. There are Western traditions of natural history, conservation, and land stewardship that take very different approaches. I'm describing a particular cultural ideal that has had a significant influence on American ideas about wilderness and our place in the natural world. It was this way of experiencing nature that my short-lived hobby gave me a taste of.
Native writers have put words to a different understanding of the relationship between people and land. In God Is Red, Vine Deloria Jr., a Standing Rock Sioux scholar, examines differences between Indigenous religious traditions and Western religious thought. One of his central arguments is that many Indigenous traditions are rooted in particular places, while Christianity places greater emphasis on historical events and a chronology of revelation. For Deloria, land is not simply the setting where a people happen to live. It is central to their spiritual and cultural understanding of the world. The stories, ceremonies, and history of a people are connected to specific places, and those places carry responsibilities that cannot simply be separated from the people themselves. Deloria describes how particular landscapes become sacred centers, giving people a way to understand their history, locate themselves in the world, and recognize their responsibilities to the land. He argues that the relationship is not built solely around what people believe about a place, but also around what they have experienced there over generations. The land and the lives of the people are intertwined. It is a relationship grounded in belonging, memory, and responsibility, rather than simply in the ability to possess or use a piece of property.
Robin Wall Kimmerer, a Potawatomi botanist and the author of Braiding Sweetgrass, describes a related distinction in how land is understood. In the Western legal and economic tradition she discusses, land is treated as property that can be bought and sold. In many Indigenous traditions, she describes it instead as a sustainer and a source of identity, home to our more-than-human relatives as well as to us. It is a place to which we have responsibilities, not merely something over which we claim rights. These are not descriptions of every Western or Indigenous person's beliefs. Deloria is discussing particular religious traditions, and Kimmerer is drawing on Indigenous perspectives that are not identical across nations. But their work points to an important difference in how the relationship itself can be understood. Land can be treated primarily as an object that people possess and use, or it can be understood as part of a living relationship that gives people a sense of identity, belonging, and responsibility. A visitor takes what the land offers and leaves when the experience is over. A relative gives, and stays.
This doesn't mean Indigenous people have never owned land, altered the environment, or used its resources. People have always farmed, hunted, built homes, and changed the places they live. Nor does it mean that Western people are incapable of having deep relationships with the land. The distinction is not simply whether humans interact with or transform the environment. It is how that relationship is understood. Is the land primarily something that belongs to us, or are we also part of something to which we belong? The land is not an inert backdrop to human life. It is part of the living world that sustains us, and we are part of it.
This relationship doesn't belong to one way of living. Deloria writes about peoples of the Plains like the Sioux. James Maffie, a philosopher who studies Nahua thought, writes about the farmers and city builders of central Mexico. They lived very differently, and they stood in the same relationship to the land. In pre-Hispanic Nahua thinking, Maffie argues in his study Aztec Philosophy, all things in nature are interdependent and bound by reciprocity, and humans are in the world as well as of the world. The title of his study says it in one line, "We eat of the earth then the earth eats us."
The Mexica show why the relationship matters more than the arrangement. On the surface, a Mexica household working its plot could look a lot like a European peasant working a strip of land someone else owned. The tenure was different. The calpulli, a neighborhood and kin unit, held its land communally. Households kept the right to use their plots, but only the calpulli as a whole could sell or rent them. In his classic study of the Aztecs, Alfonso Caso describes the commoner working the land of his own clan, while the nobles' estates were worked by people outside it. None of this makes Mexica society an egalitarian paradise. Nobles held estates, and a dependent class worked under lords. But for most households the land belonged to a community they were part of, not to a stranger who leased it to them.
The deeper difference was in what the land was. Anthropologists who work with Nahua communities in Veracruz today describe pilgrimages and offerings to Mother Earth and Father Earth as a way of practicing reciprocity with the forces that sustain the community. Modern Nahua practice has been shaped by centuries of colonial history, so I treat it as a cousin of Mexica thought and not a window into it. But it points the same direction as Maffie. The difference between the Mexica farmer and the European peasant wasn't the shape of the field. It was what the land was understood to be.
Some people say they can't connect with nature because they live in a city. I don't think the city sits outside nature. Humans are a species that makes tools. Other animals use tools too, but we build whole environments with ours. A beaver builds a dam and a pond. We build streets and buildings. Neither one steps outside of nature. A city is another biome, no different in kind from a mountain, a plain, a swamp, or a meadow. Native people have built and lived in cities for a very long time, from Pueblo Bonito to Tenochtitlán, which scholars of Indigenous urbanism say is a fact little noted. Native and city were never opposites.
That doesn't make a city automatically good. Being an expression of human nature doesn't make it moral, beneficial to the web of life, or the goal. Cities can crowd out other living things, foul the air and water, and treat everything around them as a resource. If we're part of nature, we're responsible for what we build in it. A city should be designed to be sustainable, and better than that, regenerative, giving back to the life that supports it, and reciprocal, so that what it takes it also returns.
Think about the figures we usually reach for when we picture wisdom about the living world. The old witch who knows the medicines of the forest. The Algonquin hunter who knows the woods inside and out. The Chumash who understand the sea. Now imagine someone who has spent their life in a city. They know how the birds, squirrels, and raccoons adapted to it. They know the etiquette of the streets and the professionalism of the workplace. They have watched their neighborhood long enough to know what changes in it. Their insight comes from the same two things as the others, observation and reflection.
I saw what that looks like in practice when I was brought into the powwow circle. The formal way in is through a sponsor, and mine was an Apache man named Crying Bear. When I was a young dancer, he gave me a crow wing fan. There was nothing romantic about where it came from. No one hunted for it, and it wasn't a feather found on a mountain trail. A crow was hit by a car on a busy street in Los Angeles, and it couldn't be nursed back to health. The bird was made into a fan, and Crying Bear gave it to me to bring me into the circle. A death on a city street became a gift, and the gift started a relationship. It is an example of how a Native relationship with the natural world can take shape in an urban environment. The environment was a city.
Scholars define traditional ecological knowledge as a body of knowledge, practice, and belief about how living beings relate to each other and their environment, built through adaptation and handed down through generations. Nothing in that definition says forest. A family that has lived in the same city for generations is doing the same work. So are the crows. In Seattle, researchers found that crows can tell individual human faces apart, and that they pass what they learn about threatening faces on to others, including their young. The biologist John Marzluff suspects the skill helps explain why crows thrive in cities. That is knowledge about how living beings relate to each other, handed down through generations, in a city.
The natural world doesn't stop functioning because we have built a city around it. Cities still have seasons. Plants grow, insects emerge, birds migrate, and animals adapt to the changing conditions around them. There are relationships between species, food sources, nesting places, weather patterns, and the rhythms of human activity. The crow doesn't need the city to become a forest before it can live as a crow.
My short-lived birdwatching hobby gave me a taste of a distinctly American way of experiencing nature. It was an experience built around going somewhere, looking for something, and hoping to bring back a photograph or a memory. There is nothing inherently wrong with that. But it reminded me that my relationship with the natural world has never depended on going out to find it. The land is not a destination. It is where we live. It is what sustains us, what our histories are tied to, and what connects us to the other lives around us. We don't have to travel to the mountains or retreat into the wilderness to participate in the natural world. We are already participating in it, whether we recognize that relationship or not.
Perhaps that is the most important distinction. When we think of nature as somewhere separate from human life, we begin to see ourselves as outsiders. We visit it, admire it, photograph it, and return home. But when we understand ourselves as part of the land, the relationship changes. The places where we live become part of that relationship, and so do the lives unfolding around us. The question is no longer where we must go to find nature, but how we choose to live within it. A crow in a parking lot is no less a part of the natural world than one perched in a pine tree. And the land beneath our homes is no less worthy of relationship than the wilderness we travel to admire.
Comments
Post a Comment