Is Codependency Always Bad? What Native American Culture Teaches About Mutual Support

Aztec feast from the Florentine Codex (a 16th-century ethnographic research study in Mesoamerica by the Franciscan friar Bernardino de Sahagún)

The Candy Platter

Dr. Sebastian Purcell, author of The Outward Path, tells a story about a platter of leftover Halloween candy in his living room. He couldn't resist it, and every time he grabbed a piece and ate it, he felt guilty. He hated that he couldn't stop. One day he came home and the platter was empty. His wife had taken it to the students in his philosophy department, and the cycle of guilt ended. From a Western point of view, that looks like codependency. The self-help version of Stoicism popular today, where discipline is treated as the mark of character, would say he never built the strength to handle himself and simply outsourced the problem. In contrast, the Nawa tradition Purcell writes about points toward a different way of solving problems, one that begins outward, with our surroundings and relationships, instead of only inward. In this article, I want to ask whether codependency is actually bad, or whether the better question is whether it is constructive or destructive.

I want to be clear about how I'm writing this. The essay blends two kinds of sources. One is academic work, mainly Dr. Sebastian Purcell's writing on Nawa philosophy and published translations of Nawa texts. The other is my own lived experience as an Indigenous person who grew up rooted in traditional culture, and the worldview those experiences shaped. I'll try to make clear which is which.

Beyond Good and Bad

If we ask whether codependency is good or bad, we may have already asked the wrong question. In my own experience on the Pine Ridge Reservation, the Lakota people I knew tended to think in terms of forces in tension rather than a simple battle between good and evil. In the stories I grew up with, the Wakíŋyaŋ (Thunder Beings) represent order, while Uŋktéhi, the water monsters they fight, embody chaos. This is not to say that Indigenous philosophies in the Americas lacked a concept of good and bad entirely. Rather, it simply didn't occupy the same hyper-centralized role in our thought and philosophy as it does in Western cultures.

Because of this, you cannot simply brand the Wakíŋyaŋ as 'good' and the Uŋktéhi as 'bad.' That is a deeply Western projection. A thunderstorm can flood a field and tear down a tree, yet that same storm brings the rain that allows life to grow. Neither force is purely good or purely bad. The real question is whether a force is serving a constructive purpose in a given moment. I won't claim every Native nation thinks this way, but the resonance across traditions is strong enough to take seriously. Codependency operates exactly like a storm: it has the capacity to destroy or to nourish. The better question to ask is which one it is actively doing.

From Dependence to Support

Purcell's candy platter makes a useful test case, because on the surface it looks like codependency. Codependency can go wrong in two ways. It is destructive when it feeds something that harms you, like enabling someone's addiction. It can also turn destructive even when the help itself is good, if you lean on a healthy source of support and take no responsibility for your own growth. Purcell's situation fits neither. His wife's help was good, and he wasn't dodging responsibility. He disliked what he was doing and wanted it to stop, but wanting it was not enough. She removed the trigger that his own intentions could not. When you rely on an outward source while you are still working on yourself, codependency becomes support, and that is what happened here. He accepted help with something he had already shown he couldn't solve alone. He surely appreciated what she did, and for a small kindness like that, a simple thank you honors it. The bigger and longer the help, the more the person receiving it will want to give back.

I'm using the word codependency the way most people use it in everyday speech, as the accusation that someone leans on others instead of standing on their own. By that meaning, the line between codependency and support comes down to what a person does with the help. Say someone gives you a ride to work every day so you can get on your feet financially. If you take the ride and the money goes nowhere constructive, that is codependency, and a bad form of it, even though the help itself is good. If instead you use the ride to become more financially responsible, save up, and eventually get your own transportation, the same help has become support.

There is one more step. When that person also honors the driver, by filling the tank, giving a gift, or showing thanks in whatever way they can, support becomes mutual support. Giving back to the person who helped you is a matter of respect, and failing to do so is disrespectful. Mutual does not mean the exchange has to be equal or immediate. What matters is that the person gives back as they are able, and that they also take on their own responsibility to be accommodating to the family, friends, and community around them. Help moves in both directions, and it keeps moving outward. The help is the same in every case. What differs is what the person does with it and what they give back.

The Responsibility to Give Back

There is also a reason this kind of reliance is not a weakness, and it has to do with what the person owes in return. A useful source on how the Nawa thought about this is the Bancroft Dialogues, a set of imagined conversations between generations that Pablo of Texcoco, a Nawa man trained in formal speaking, wrote down in the late 1500s. Frances Karttunen and Camilla Townsend published a new translation in 2025 as How to Be Grateful. One reviewer calls them among the best sources we have for reconstructing pre-European Nawa thought, though they do show some Christian influence. As the translators describe them, the dialogues treat gratitude as more than a feeling. It is something owed to the living, the dead, and the divine, and it gets repaid by helping your people and securing the future for those still to come. Among the Lakota, I grew up with a similar idea of thinking seven generations ahead.

The idea of giving back also ran through Nawa life at a much larger scale. The word nextlawalistli referred to offerings made to the gods, such as incense, paper, and rubber, and in some contexts blood sacrifice. I'm not borrowing it as a word for thanks, since it was a sacred and sometimes violent practice, but it shows how deeply reciprocity ran through the Nawa world. One scholar even argues that calling it a debt hides its reciprocal character, so I would frame it as exchange and not as a burden. In my own experience, the Lakota practice of wóphila carries a similar spirit. When a community member has been supported, they might put on a feast or a giveaway as their wóphila, giving back to the people who held them up. Thanks is something you do, not just something you say.

Go back to the person getting rides to work. Their growth shows the driver the help was not wasted, and their thanks is their wóphila. In my experience, it would not be unusual for them to fill the driver's gas tank or give a small gift along the way, a visible way of saying thanks while the help is still coming. The person who takes the rides, gives nothing back, and does nothing to change their situation is the one who has slipped into codependency. Support takes and grows. Mutual support takes, grows, and returns.

Reciprocity has a shadow side, and it needs to be named. In my experience, especially on the reservation, some people who offer help hold it over the head of the person they helped, using it as leverage to demand repayment. That is not okay, and it is not mutual support. Help should come from the helper's own commitment to their role as an accommodating person, not as a means of self-gain. The person receiving help is expected to give back in whatever way they can, even if that is as simple as showing up, trying, and saying thanks. The person who gave it should not be the one to expect it, because expecting repayment is not good manners. Support that comes with strings is not the kind most of us would want to receive.

Rooted on Slippery Earth

I believe the deeper reason the Nawa lean on community is that they do not expect a person to conquer their own mind. Shaped by growing up in a Native community, my understanding is that the mind is always some degree of chaos, and the struggle never fully ends. The Nawa teaching of the slippery earth speaks to that. It appears in the Wewetlatolli, a collection of speeches from Nawa elders to the young that Purcell translated as Discourses of the Elders. These texts were collected by Spanish friars, so scholars debate how much Christian influence shaped them, and Purcell's reading is a careful reconstruction and not a perfectly clear window.

In one passage the elders say the earth is not a good place, only a place of joy-fatigue and joy-pain, and that it is slippery and slick. In Purcell's account, the Nawa answer is rootedness, taking root so that you don't fall. We will make mistakes, and sometimes others will disappoint us. Expecting anyone to master themselves alone would be close to foolish. In the world these texts describe, no one was expected to carry life alone.

The Stoics would partly agree on the difficulty, since they treated the sage as an ideal so rare it is nearly unobtainable. The difference is what each path does with that fact. The self-help Stoic keeps pressing the individual toward the ideal, and some would say that relying on anything outside yourself is the opposite of building discipline. To be fair to the Stoics, the real philosophers of that tradition also valued community and our duties to one another, so this critique is aimed at the self-help version and not the whole school. The Nawa path says that if perfect self-mastery is unlikely, community has to carry part of the weight.

This is also where the two paths part ways on control. A Stoic would say that receiving help from others is outside your control, since you cannot guarantee that help will come, or what form it will take. What is up to you is your own judgment and choices. The Nawa philosophy, as I understand it, would push back. This is my own reading of how it would respond, based on what I feel the philosophy represents, and not something Purcell or the Nawa texts state directly.

The reply would be that Purcell clearly could not control himself either. He wanted to stop, he felt guilty every time, and he still reached for the candy. Are our own actions really as much in our control as the Stoics suggest? Is it reasonable to expect anyone to fully control all of their actions? A Stoic might answer that his judgment about the candy was still his to command, even when his self-discipline failed him. The Nawa question is how reliable that kind of control is in real life. If it is not very reliable, then leaning on the people around us is a sensible response and not a failure of character.

What We Hold for Each Other

That kind of outward thinking shows up in small ways too. Recently my family and I were leaving a doctor's appointment and we couldn't settle on where to eat. Everyone had a different idea and nobody could land on one. I asked the medical assistant if he had any suggestions, and he mentioned a pho place. None of us would have thought of that on our own, but the second he said it, it just clicked for everybody. We reached outside our little circle, got an idea we couldn't have come up with ourselves, and the problem solved itself. The candy platter took something harmful out of Purcell's environment, and the pho suggestion brought something good into ours.

The pho story shows what we can receive from the people around us. A story from my childhood shows the other side, what they can count on us for. When I was very young, before I lived on Pine Ridge, I grew up in a mostly Chicano neighborhood in Wilmington, California. A gardener, a man from Mexico, asked me and two friends to help him mow the church field across from our house, the same field we played sports on. When we finished, he tore a one dollar bill into three pieces and gave one to each of us. He told us that when he came back in a few weeks, if all three of us brought our piece, we would each be paid five dollars. Only two of us still had our piece, so none of us got paid.

At the time that stung, but the lesson was worth more than the money. Nobody could collect alone. Each of us held a third of the dollar, and one missing piece cost all three of us, including the two who had kept theirs safe. Our responsibility was never only to ourselves. It was also to the other two, and theirs was to us. That is mutual support at its simplest. We depend on other people, and other people depend on us.

It would be easy to take the wrong lesson from it and blame whoever lost their piece. Looking back, I think the deeper lesson is that none of us was only responsible for ourselves. We could have kept track of each other's pieces, reminded each other, or kept them together. Being reliable is part of what we owe the people who rely on us, and a good community helps its members stay reliable instead of only blaming them when they slip.

I'm not claiming it was fair to withhold pay from kids who did real work, and I wouldn't hold it up as a model for how to treat workers. I'm telling it for the lesson. In my interpretation, he was teaching us mutual support and shared responsibility, and how one person's irresponsibility can affect everyone else. I can't say he was consciously drawing on Nawa philosophy, but I see the same sense of shared responsibility in Nawa thought, a form of reciprocity and shared mutual support on a community scale. I believe it is still alive in people of Mexican descent today.

Staying Rooted

Is codependency bad? Not by nature. It is destructive when it enables harm, and it is destructive when we lean on something good and refuse to grow alongside it. When we rely on others while we keep working on ourselves, it is no longer codependency. It is support. When we also honor the people who held us up, it becomes mutual support, which fits the spirit of Nawa reciprocity as I understand it. Mutual support also means being someone others can count on, as the gardener's dollar taught me. Self-discipline still matters, partly because our choices land on other people, but treating it as the only legitimate tool is a cultural assumption, not a universal truth. The Nawa view and the lived wisdom I saw growing up both treat a person as part of a web of relationships. Asking for help while you keep growing is not a failure of strength. It is a way of staying rooted.

Comments